Whats This About Staples?
High 5s view of staples as leading edge anchor points
In November of 2003 ACCT put out a position statement:
Tests conducted by the ACCT Installation Standards Committee indicate that the strength of staples used on challenge courses can vary widely. There are a number of factors, which can affect the strength including the type of wood supporting the staple, the length and size of the staple, the depth to which the staple has been driven, and whether or not holes were predrilled as part of the installation. Staples that have been properly installed by an experienced course builder generally are suitable and should not pose an immediate hazard when used as anchors in leading edge climbing. However, even when properly installed, it can be very difficult to verify that each staple placement is strong enough to meet the 2500 lb. (11.1 kN) ACCT standard. Changing conditions in trees or utility poles over time can also affect the strength of staples adding to the difficulty of verifying their strength and suitability.
For existing courses, the use of staples as anchors should be strictly limited to those situations where it can reasonably be verified that such anchors comply with Standard B7.2 Leading Edge Anchors (i.e. 2500 lbs or 11.1 kN). Where such verification cannot reasonably be accomplished, then approved alternative systems for fall protection must be employed. Ultimately, ACCT is recommending the adoption of alternative systems to replace the use of staples as anchors in leading edge climbing.
High 5 strongly suggest that everyone using staples as protection points carefully read the entire ACCT document. It is available on line at www.acctinfo.org, or by calling our office. The test data is also available on the web page.
The ACCT memo is a well thought out and written document on the ten years of sporadic data gathering on the holding power of staples in a wide variety of mediums. These mediums include Utility Poles, Hardwood and Softwood Trees. The test date has shown that the holding power of staples has a large range making it very difficult to evaluate and assure the required load for a leading edge anchor point as defined by ACCT standards under section B7.2 Leading Edge Anchors. There are many factors that play into the holding power of the staples including depth, density of the medium, environmental impact and placement techniques.
ACCT has summarized their recommendations with the following, ... leading edge climbing be limited to properly trained individuals on climbs where suitable anchors are available. The use of staples as anchors should be strictly limited to those situations where it can reasonably be verified that such anchors comply with Standard B7.2 Leading Edge Anchors (i.e. 2500 lbs or 11.1 kN). Where such verification cannot reasonably be accomplished, then approved alternative systems for fall protection must be employed.
In line with ACCTs recommendations High 5 is sending out this statement and is updating training procedures to raise the awareness of this new information. We will work with each of our clients during annual course inspections to evaluate and make recommendations regarding available anchors and alternative systems wear needed. We will help programs plan for a suitable time line to update Leading Edge climbing systems. It is important to gather information about when staples were placed and by whom. This information can help determine the suitability of the staples as protection points. We recommend that until you have had your annual inspection you should limit your exposure with haul line systems and good climbing practices. If you have concerns or questions please give us a call.
High 5 will continue to use staples as part of the element access system, and will design, install and train staff, on the proper use of climbing protection systems suitable for the medium on which their course is built.